In a landmark decision that has sparked significant debate about the role of unregulated experts in family court proceedings, a UK family court judge has ordered the removal of a child from her mother’s care, placing her with her father against the child’s own wishes. This ruling, which has profound implications for the family involved and potentially for the wider legal system, was heavily influenced by the recommendations of an unregulated psychotherapist, Karen Woodall.
Background of the Case
The case revolved around a family with a daughter of secondary school age. The mother and father were embroiled in a custody dispute, with the mother making serious allegations against the father. These allegations were later deemed to be entirely false by Mr Justice Keehan, the presiding judge.
The Role of Karen Woodall
Central to the case was the involvement of Karen Woodall, a psychotherapist who is not registered with any UK regulatory body. Woodall was one of three experts assessing the family, and her recommendation played a crucial role in the final decision. She advised that the mother should have only very restricted supervised contact with her daughter, who would also require ongoing therapy. This recommendation was supported by Hessel Willemsen, a regulated clinical psychologist.
The Mother’s Challenge and Allegations
The mother in the case attempted unsuccessfully to have Woodall removed from her case, arguing that Woodall’s recommendation was “punitive to the extreme” and motivated by financial interests. However, Woodall defended her position in court, stating that her recommendation followed serious safeguarding concerns.
Judicial Findings and Decision
Mr Justice Keehan found that the mother had made an entirely false allegation about the father having a sexual interest in their daughter. He also criticized the child’s guardian for suggesting a shared living arrangement, describing her analysis as “woeful.” Keehan accepted Woodall’s advice that there needed to be a fundamental shift in the living arrangements for the girl, referred to as A in court documents.
The Debate Over Unregulated Experts
The case has brought to the forefront the ongoing debate about the use of unregulated experts in family court. MPs have raised concerns, and the Family Justice Council has advised that UK-based practitioner psychologists providing evidence in family proceedings should be regulated. Despite this, Woodall, who describes herself as a psychotherapist, was appointed to the case.
The Outcome and Its Implications
The judge ordered a transfer of residence to the father and initially four supervised contact sessions with the mother, at her cost. The success of these sessions would determine the possibility of moving to unsupervised contact. The father was also instructed to fund Woodall to oversee further therapeutic work for the child.
Conclusion
This case highlights the complexities and challenges in family court proceedings, especially concerning the use of unregulated experts. It raises important questions about the balance between professional expertise and regulatory oversight in sensitive family matters. The decision, while legally binding, leaves open a broader conversation about the best practices in family law and the protection of children’s welfare.
What To Do Now
If you’re considering divorce or separation, family mediation offers a constructive, cost-effective way to resolve disputes without the stress and expense of going to court. By working with a professionally trained mediator, you can reach practical agreements that reflect the needs and interests of everyone involved — especially children.
At We Mediate, we provide a comprehensive range of services to support you through every stage of your separation. Our experienced and accredited mediators help you navigate complex issues such as financial arrangements, child contact schedules, co-parenting strategies, and communication challenges, all in a safe and confidential setting.
We believe every family deserves a fair, respectful, and accessible path through separation. Our focus is on creating balanced outcomes that prioritise the wellbeing of all parties, and our commitment to affordability means we can support families across England and Wales, no matter their circumstances.
Before starting mediation, you will need to attend a MIAM — a Mediation Information and Assessment Meeting. This is a confidential one-to-one session with an accredited family mediator, where you’ll learn more about how mediation works and whether it’s suitable for your situation. We can usually arrange MIAMs quickly, often within 24–48 hours, with daytime and evening appointments available. Book your MIAM today to take the first step towards resolving matters in a more cooperative and less adversarial way.
If you’re ready to explore a more amicable approach to divorce or separation, we invite you to browse our website or contact us directly. Whether you’re just beginning to consider your options or are already in the midst of proceedings, our team is here to guide and support you at every stage. Schedule your consultation today and discover how mediation can help you move forward with clarity and confidence.
You can call us on 0333 567 1676 or click here to send us a confidential email.
